Extramarital sexual relationships permanently undermine the foundation of trust that supports a marriage, while at the same time causing long-lasting damage to a spouse’s sense of confidence and wellbeing. The effects of adultery become even more complicated when you have children or when you share significant economic assets with your spouse.
If you are struggling through the aftermath of adultery, our attorneys can work as your personal legal adviser to explore your avenues for independence and recovery. With offices in Marietta and Kennesaw, our team is here to support you through divorce and other family law issues.
Contact us today at (770) 956-4030 for a FREE divorce consultation.
What is adultery?
As defined under O.C.G.A. § 16-6-19, a “married person commits the offense of adultery when he [or she] voluntarily has sexual intercourse with a person other than his [or her] spouse.” Though adultery is technically listed under the Georgia Criminal Code as a misdemeanor criminal offense, this crime is rarely (if ever) enforced or prosecuted by state officials. Instead, adultery is enumerated as one of the grounds for terminating a marriage by total divorce. See O.C.G.A. § 19-5-3 (“Grounds for total divorce”). Under Georgia law, total divorce is the process by which the ties of marriage are dissolved and each party is released from their respective matrimonial obligations. According to a case in the Superior Court of Cobb County, the result of a total divorce is that (1) the marital contract is dissolved “as if no such contract had even been made or entered into,” (2) each spouse “in the future shall be held and considered as [a] separate and distinct person,” and (3) each spouse “shall have the right to remarry.” See Philogene v. Morgan, Cobb County Sup. Ct. (2017). Total divorce is sometimes referred to by its Latin name, “divorce a vinculo matrimonii.”
Here are some important legal considerations about Georgia adultery laws:
- Adultery may occur in extramarital relationships that are either heterosexual or homosexual in nature. See Owens v. Owens, Supreme Ct. of Georgia (1981).
- Adultery must occur during the course of the marriage. Extramarital sexual relationships before the marriage are not sufficient to establish grounds for divorce. For example, if a partner commits adultery while dating or engaged, the crime of adultery has not been committed because there was no existing marriage at the time. See Stanley v. Stanley, Supreme Ct. of Georgia (1902).
- If a spouse files for divorce and later finds out that their partner had an extramarital affair during the marriage, the spouse can amend the divorce filing to include adultery as a ground for divorce. See Hargrett v. Hargrett, Supreme Ct. of Georgia (1978).
How to Prove Adultery in Georgia?
What happens if your spouse engages in an outside sexual relationship, but you don’t have any concrete evidence to prove the adulterous conduct occurred? Proving adultery can be difficult, because the evidentiary burden is on you to show that your spouse was engaging in such conduct. When it comes to proving adultery in Georgia, the following methods may be sufficient to prove that your spouse engaged in adultery or cheating:
Admission: The most decisive way to prove adultery is by admission under oath. See Hathcock v. Hathcock, Supreme Ct. of Georgia (1982). During divorce proceedings, a party may seek to elicit “testimony as to whether or not [the spouse] had a sexual relationship with the alleged [extramarital partner].” Id. The problem is that obtaining this kind of testimony is rare. Spouses do not want to admit to committing adultery, and more importantly, Georgia has enacted certain statutory protections to shield parties from giving up this kind incriminating and embarrassing testimony. Specifically, O.C.G.A. § 24-5-505 permits witnesses to remain silent if asked to testify “as to any matter which may incriminate or tend to incriminate such party or witness or which shall tend to bring infamy, disgrace, or public contempt upon such party or witness[.]”
Circumstantial Evidence: Adultery is usually proved by circumstantial evidence. See Popham v. Popham, Supreme Ct. of Georgia (2005). Unlike direct evidence of sexual intercourse between an adulterous spouse and a third party, circumstantial evidence is indirect in nature. Circumstantial evidence tends to show that, based on a collection of various facts, sexual intercourse was likely to have occurred between the spouse and the third party. Circumstantial evidence must create an inference that (1) the spouse had an opportunity to commit adultery and (2) the spouse had an adulterous disposition. See Johnson v. Johnson, Supreme Ct. of Georgia (1962). The following types of circumstantial evidence may form the basis for establishing that adultery has occurred:
- Secretive Vacations or Meetings with Partners: In the divorce proceeding of Johnson v. Johnson (Supreme Ct. of Georgia, 1962), the court upheld the use of circumstantial evidence related to the wife’s out-of-state vacations with another man. Specifically, the husband presented evidence that the wife had traveled to another state, was seen at a motel with another man, was seen dining with the man, and was registered checking into the same hotel room as the man. This circumstantial evidence here was sufficient to show that the wife engaged in adultery. This type of fact pattern can be common in divorce proceedings.
- Prior Extramarital Affairs:In the divorce proceeding of Popham v. Popham (Supreme Ct. of Georgia, 2005), the court upheld the admissibility of circumstantial evidence related to the husband’s previous history of infidelity and the husband’s secretive Viagra prescription. A spouse’s history of infidelity can be used as circumstantial evidence for a divorce proceeding.
- Texts and Emails: In the divorce proceeding of Ewing v. Ewing (Ct. of Appeals of Georgia, 2015), a husband was caught sending sexually explicit emails and text messages to another woman. The Court of Appeals of Georgia held that these messages could be circumstantial evidence of adultery and that the wife could seek discovery of such messages by subpoena. Today, as spouses turn to social media to connect with new and old lovers, these virtual records have become more important than ever. Finding incriminating text messages is one of the most common ways that spouses learn about their partner’s infidelity
- Third-Party Witnesses: In some cases, parties may seek statements from third-party witnesses about a spouse’s adulterous encounters. Neighbors, friends, coworkers, or family members may observe the spouse engaging in conduct that suggests an extramarital affair. For example, neighbors may observe an unidentified car parked in the driveway, or friends may observe scandalous behavior after a night out. Your lawyer may seek to collect statements or testimony from these third-party witnesses to provide circumstantial evidence that adultery has occurred.
- Physical Evidence: It is not uncommon for spouses to find physical evidence of adultery. For example, personal items (like jewelry or clothing) may be found in a spouse’s personal effects. By itself, this evidence may not establish that adultery has occurred; however, it may be combined with other forms of circumstantial evidence to prove adultery.
- Other Circumstantial Evidence: Every divorce case is different, and there is no one-size-fits-all method for proving adultery. If you are suspicious of your spouse’s extramarital activity and are considering divorce, then you should speak with an attorney to assess your options. Your attorney will ask what information you already know and who may have additional information about the spouse’s conduct. Most importantly, your attorney will explain what this information means in a legal context and what additional information you may need to obtain to prove your case.
Defenses to Adultery
In some cases, a spouse may be able to reject a claim of adultery by arguing that the adulterous conduct was approved by their spouse or forgiven by their spouse. Thus, even when a spouse engages in adulterous conduct, such conduct may not always serve as the basis for divorce. The following three defenses, found in O.C.G.A. § 19-5-4, are defenses to claims of adultery:
1. Connivance: Connivance occurs when “the party complaining of the adultery…was consenting thereto.” For example, if one spouse approves of the other’s extramarital sexual relations, then the approving spouse cannot petition the court for divorce on the basis of adultery. Connivance may be an issue for married couples that have an open relationship or that are involved in swinger communities.
2. Condonation: Condonation is “forgiveness, either expressed or implied, by a husband of his wife, or by a wife of her husband, for a breach of marital duty, with an implied condition that the offense shall not be repeated.” See Phinizy v. Phinizy, Supreme Ct. of Georgia (1922). Under O.C.G.A. § 19-5-4, this defense requires “voluntary condonation and cohabitation subsequent to the acts complained of, with notice thereof.” In other words, a spouse may defend against allegations of adultery if (a) the other spouse learns of the adulterous activity, (b) the other spouse forgives such conduct, and then (c) the spouses continue to live together. The defense of condonation can be complicated, as many spouses face social and family pressures to remain in their marriage, even despite instances of adultery. In many cases, a spouse may verbally forgive their partner for an affair, even though the marriage is irreconcilably broken. To understand how these facts might affect you, we always suggest speaking with an attorney.
3. Recrimination: If “[b]oth parties are guilty of like conduct,” then adultery cannot be a valid basis for divorce. See O.C.G.A. § 19-5-4. Referred to as recrimination, this legal principle suggests that a spouse cannot allege adultery while at the same time engaging in the adulterous behavior. For example, if both spouses are engaging in adulterous relationships during the marriage, then neither can argue for divorce on the basis of adultery. Similarly, if one spouse engages in an affair as a way to seek revenge for the other partner’s affair, then it is unlikely that either spouse can allege adultery against the other.
While defenses to adultery are rare, they still have modern legal implications for divorce cases across the State of Georgia. Make sure you discuss some of these issues with your divorce attorney.
Finding a Divorce Lawyer in Cobb County, Georgia
The team of divorce attorneys at Fennell, Briasco & Associates™ have decades of combined experience working on Georgia divorce cases. Our team has handled countless cases related to adultery and extramarital affairs, while navigating all the complicated issues related to child custody, property division, and Georgia divorce law.
Equipped with expert negotiation skills, our attorneys are ready to fight on your behalf for what matters most. Our job is to move your case forward and help you find the best path towards stability and independence during and after a divorce.
If you believe your spouse is engaged in an extramarital affair, it is time to consult an attorney. Call us today at (770) 956-4030 to request a FREE divorce consultation. We proudly serve clients throughout Cobb County, Cherokee County, Forsyth County, Fulton County, Pickens County, and Paulding County.